The Mel Brooks Musical Young Frankenstein is a wild and witty romp through Romania, and the Square Foot Theatre’s current production—running through August 16—is nothing short of a giddy good time. Directed by Patrick Laffin and choreographed by Emma Kelly, this community theatre production captures the campy charm of the original 1974 film co-authored by Mel Brooks and Gene Wilder, and the Broadway musical that opened in 2007, with music and lyrics written by Mel Brooks and a book co-authored by Thomas Meehan. The story follows a young Dr. Frederick Frankenstein who, after learning of his uncle, Dr. Victor Frankenstein’s death, travels back to Transylvania. There, he must then decide whether or not to continue the “family business” of bringing monsters to life.
From the moment you enter the Square Foot Theatre & Tavern, it’s clear there is a youthful energy and production camaraderie that only real community theatre can possess. An impressive live orchestra is led by pianist-conductor, Alan Doherty, who is supported by Bob Cogan (percussion), Steven Anderson (bass), and Lisa Naples (violin). Together they provide a satisfying musical backdrop for a romp (or “Roll in the Hay!”) through Romania and the catchy tunes, well-executed harmonies, and upbeat dance numbers of the show—from tight barbershop-style harmonies in “Welcome to Transylvania” to a well-executed fugue in “Transylvania Mania,” the live orchestra and vocal performers deliver with clarity and confidence.
As the hunchbacked Igor, David Nunner is a consistent scene-stealer, leaning into the physical comedy and oddball charisma the role demands. His timing is sharp, and his presence is true electricity on stage. Tullio Milani offers Nunner balance and gives a strong performance as Dr. Frederick Frankenstein. His chemistry with Nunner during “Together Again,” where they blend together strong vocals and physical comedy, just adds to the lunacy on stage. They look like they are having as much fun up there together as we are having out here in the audience watching them. Kudos to both of these well-seasoned performers for stepping up to show us all “how it’s done!”
Inga (Jamie Dumaine-Russell) Frankenstein’s lab assistant, impresses with her vocals and comic timing as well. In fact, many of the ladies in the cast gave strong vocal performances, including Ellie Mountcastle (Elizabeth Benning) and Theresa Moscato (Frau Blücher) whose expansive ranges give the audience a real treat during their solo numbers “Deep Love” and “He Vas My Boyfriend,” respectively. Also, Scott “Scooter” Hauser (Inspector Hans Kemp) offers memorable vocals during “The Law” and “He’s Loose.” Heather Caldwell (The Hermit) also delivers great vocals and well-timed comedy during her scenes and solo number, “Please Send Me Someone.” Further, ensemble member Grace Persaud shines in every dance number adding extra spins and kicks to increase the difficulty and challenge herself onstage. However, Kelly’s overall choreography remains accessible and fun for all ability levels. The cast looks happy and confident on stage, which allows them all to lean even more into the physical humor and absurd comedy the show demands.
The show's visual elements add to its delightfully spooky aesthetic. The set design is thoughtfully detailed with a playful, campy flair that matches the absurdity of the story. Jeffrey Thibodeau (Technical Director) and Melissa Thibodeau (Production Manager) ensure the lighting cues are well-timed and appropriate. This creates a playful and immersive stage environment. Makeup Artist, Taylor Klein, completes the “monster” magic and keeps the show on-theme.
The atmosphere of the Square Foot Theatre & Tavern is deeply community-focused, with young people engaging audiences at concessions and 50/50 drawings. It’s a reminder that this is more than a production—it’s a celebration of local talent, collaboration, and creative energy. I only wished for a QR code in the program or a bulletin board in the lobby, so I could read cast bios.
Sponsored by the Jamie Hulley Arts Foundation, The Mel Brooks Musical Young Frankenstein at Square Foote Theatre & Tavern is a “can’t-miss” night out for fans of musical comedy, classic horror, parodies, or just a good laugh. It is an electrifying production you don’t want to miss!
The Mel Brooks Musical Young Frankenstein runs through August 16th at Square Foote Theatre & Tavern in Wallingford. Tickets can be purchased online at https://www.squarefoottheatre.com