Million Dollar Quartet is a Sure Bet: Sharon Playhouse Delivers an Electrifying Rock ‘n’ Roll Revival

Sharon Playhouse’s production of Million Dollar Quartet in Sharon, CT (June 20- July 6) delivers a rousing “Hillbilly Homecoming!” and a thrilling, high-energy tribute to a legendary moment in music history.  This jukebox musical, originally a Broadway musical with Book by Colin Escott and Floyd Mutrux, was originally conceptualized and directed by Floyd Mutrux as well.  It is based upon a fictional retelling of a true story.  Million Dollar Quartet, tells the story of how Carl Perkins (Chance Michael Wall), Johnny Cash (Matthew Schatz), Elvis Presley (Alessandro Gian Viviano), and Jerry Lee Lewis (Alex Burnette) came together at Sun Records on December 4, 1956 to have a special session with the man who discovered them, Sun Records founder and rock ‘n’ roll producing pioneer, Sam Phillips (Zac Cossman).  

Sharon Playhouse’s production is under the musical direction of Chance Michael Wall (who also performs as Carl Perkins in the show), keeps the audience clapping and toe-tapping from start to finish.  However, the entire production comes together under the skillful direction of Greg Santos, who strikes a satisfying balance between storytelling, musicality, and crowd-pleasing spectacle.  With infectious enthusiasm and exceptional musical talent, the cast of “quadruple-threat” performers who can not only sing, dance, and act, but also play instruments, brings this unforgettable jam session to life.

Cossman’s portrayal of Sam Phillips anchors the show. His opening monologue immediately engages the audience and breaks the fourth wall with charm. His performance builds steadily, simmering until it reaches a dynamic boil by the show’s end. Likewise, Burnette’s wildly entertaining turn as Jerry Lee Lewis is a standout—physically animated, musically fierce, and irresistibly likable. He threatens to steal the spotlight in the quartet, if it were not for the equally strong performances from Wall, Schatz, Viviano. The relational dynamics between the cast members adds emotional depth, particularly the tension between veteran Perkins and the brash, rising star, Lewis. Their initial clashes, along with glimpses into all of the artists’ personal losses and career frustrations, humanize these icons and deepen our connections  to the men behind the iconic music they created.  

Wall’s portrayal of Carl Perkins gains depth through a flashback that subtly parallels his younger self with the rising Lewis, shedding light on their present tension. Wall, who also serves as Musical Director, shines again on electric guitar with Schatz during “Folsom Prison Blues” where their charisma is undeniable.  In addition, Schatz’s guitar skills and bass-baritone vocals as Johnny Cash are rich and smooth, especially notable in “(Ghost) Riders in the Sky,” which visibly moved the audience and had certain nearby patrons swooning. His humble, grounded presence provides a compelling contrast to the flashier characters around him, accentuating his unique character.  As Elvis, Viviano delivers solid lead vocals, exemplary guitar skills, and smooth dance moves, but his most memorable moments come when he is not in the spotlight. In these jam sessions, Viviano delivers a lesser known side of Elvis, allowing him to shine as the collaborative musician he was in real life. In his performance, Viviano captures Elvis’ duality of being both a superstar and a bandmate —a balance that’s often overlooked, but is portrayed by Viviano with nuance and success.

The supporting roles in Million Dollar Quartet add richness and humor to the production as well. Lucy Rhoades (Dyanne), Josh Karam (Jay Perkins), and Alex Sisco (W.S. “Fluke” Holland) each leave a lasting impression. Rhoades brings warmth and an expansive vocal range to Dyanne, particularly in “I Hear You Knocking,” where Wheeler Moon’s evocative lighting design bathes the stage in moody blues and greens to accurately complement the style of the song. In addition, Sisco’s drum solo kicks off Act II with flair, while Karam’s inventive antics as Jay Perkins seemingly transform his bass instrument into a character of its own on stage.

The technical elements of Million Dollar Quartet elevate the production while standing out on their own too.  Sound Designer, Graham Stone, brings voices, instruments, and all audio into perfect balance throughout the show, especially notable during the production’s soulful rendition of “Peace in the Valley.”  Set designers Christopher and Justin Swader create a warm, nostalgic space with subtle nods to Sun Records’ humble roots such as hub caps over the doorway and peg board walls.  Their vision is also brought to life by Scenic Artist, Karla Woodworth’s painting that reflects a space worn by use, not neglect. Further, Bobbie Zlotnik’s wigs and makeup suit each character perfectly and add to capturing the time period accurately, while Kathleen DeAngelis’ vibrant costumes close the show with a kaleidoscope of colors worthy of “The King” himself, ending  the evening in true showbiz style.

The audience response to Million Dollar Quartet was electric. During intermission, fans were already raving—and by curtain call, they were even more enthusiastic. Kathy from Torrington, attending Sharon’s production for a second time with her granddaughter, declared this production “hands-down the best” she’d seen, out of eight different versions she has seen over the years. Her grand-daughter loved the show and their shared joy was a testament to the show’s cross-generational appeal.

In every way, Million Dollar Quartet is a triumph for the Sharon Playhouse—from its cast, crew, and creative team to its dedicated volunteers— who were beyond gracious and helpful during my visit. A special thanks to Herman for finding me in the parking lot with a copy of the long form playbill, after our conversation at the end of the show.  Million Dollar Quartet will run until July 6th at the Sharon Playhouse in Sharon, CT.  With an open air bar and homemade pizza made by Armando available, Sharon Playhouse offers a comfortable and relaxing evening or matinee adventure for young and old alike.  Whether you’re a lifelong fan of rock ‘n’ roll or discovering it for the first time, Million Dollar Quartet is a sure bet!